New Features Are Here!   Community Scores & Reviews Are LIVE!   Rate Games & Write Your Own Reviews!   Missing a Game? Request It!

Belly ScoreBELLYSCORE
Log InJoin Free
BELLYSCORE
SCORED
Red Dead Redemption 2

Red Dead Redemption 2

Belly Score
9.7
Community Score
Released
Developer
Rockstar Studios
Publisher
Rockstar Games
About

Forget the high-octane chaos you might expect from Rockstar; this is a deliberate, mud-caked odyssey through the dying days of the American frontier. You play as Arthur Morgan, a weary outlaw caught in the slow, grinding gears of civilization. It is a massive, obsessive simulation where you spend as much time grooming your horse and tracking game as you do pulling off high-stakes heists. The world is hauntingly alive, demanding patience and rewarding those who soak in its gritty, melancholic atmosphere. It is less of a power fantasy and more of a slow-burn tragedy that forces you to live in the dirt, sweat, and blood of a vanishing era.

The Belly's Verdict

BELLY APPROVED

The Belly's ReviewOfficial
9.7

RED DEAD REDEMPTION 2 — The Belly's Final Verdict

Red Dead Redemption 2 makes the dying Wild West feel painfully alive. Arthur Morgan rides with Dutch van der Linde's gang as loyalty curdles into doubt, and the smallest moments hit hardest: a campfire conversation, a stranger on the roadside, a quiet ride through the rain. Rockstar's world is very detailed, from wildlife and changing weather to towns that seem to breathe without you. Hunting, poker and chance encounters make wandering as rewarding as the main story. But that devotion to realism comes at a price. Looting takes forever, movement can feel heavy, and missions often punish creativity by demanding one exact approach. The opening is slow enough to lose impatient players, while Red Dead Online never matches the campaign's emotional pull. Still, Arthur's journey gives all that deliberate pacing a purpose. Red Dead Redemption 2 isn't just a cowboy fantasy; it's a devastating portrait of a man trying to become better before time runs out. Its flaws are real. So is its greatness.

Belly Score: 9.7/10 — BELLY APPROVED

The Belly Doesn't Lie.

Belly Score Calculation
Category
Weight
Score
Weighted
Fun Factor
25%
9.5
2.375
Game Play
20%
9.8
1.960
Controls + Feel
15%
9.1
1.365
Creativity + Originality
10%
10.0
1.000
Presentation
10%
10.0
1.000
Content + Staying Power
10%
10.0
1.000
The Belly Factor
10%
10.0
1.000
Total
100%
9.7
Raw weighted sum 9.700 → rounded to 9.7

Prediction Results

No predictions were made for this game.
Vibe Tags
Themes
Original Belly Score Video

Related Games

Community Reviews

0 Reviews

Members' own words beside their own community score — the community's view. The official Belly Score is set separately.

Log in to review this game.

Log in to Review
No reviews yet. Be the first to weigh in.

Community Discussion

0 Threads

Nobody's weighed in yet — be the first to call it.

Log in to join the discussion.

Log in to Comment
No comments yet. Be the first to weigh in.

Think The Belly got it wrong?Prove it.

Free account. Rate games, make predictions, and see your taste profile.

Join FreeAlready a member? Log in

Cookies. We use essential cookies to keep you logged in and the platform secure — no advertising trackers. By using Belly Score, you agree to our use of cookies. See our Privacy Policy for the details.

Privacy Policy