New Features Are Here!   Community Scores & Reviews Are LIVE!   Rate Games & Write Your Own Reviews!   Missing a Game? Request It!

Belly ScoreBELLYSCORE
Log InJoin Free
BELLYSCORE
VIBE

Best Mysterious Games

Every game with a Mysterious vibe, ranked by Belly Score. These are the titles The Belly felt hit that Mysterious note, sorted from the highest verdict down.

Games tagged with a Mysterious vibe, ranked by Belly Score. Vibe tags describe how a game feels to play — the mood and texture of the experience — so this list groups titles that share that Mysterious energy even across different genres. Browse to find games that hit the Mysterious note you're after, scored and verdict-ready.

Best Mysterious Games rankings

104 games
Echo
9.2

Echo

Visual Novel · Horror

Windows · macOS · Linux · Android

PsychologicalSurrealDark / Grim
MysteriousUnsettlingDark+3
Comment
Shin Megami Tensei: Digital Devil Saga
9.2

Shin Megami Tensei: Digital Devil Saga

RPG

PlayStation 2 · PlayStation 3

Sci-FiDystopianMythology+1
MysteriousDarkIntense+3
Comment
CONTROL
9.2

CONTROL

Action · Adventure

PlayStation 4 · PlayStation 5 · Xbox One · Xbox Series X/S · PC · Nintendo Switch · Amazon Luna · Google Stadia · macOS

Sci-FiSupernaturalPsychological+1
MysteriousImmersiveAtmospheric+3
Comment
Pathologic 3
9.1

Pathologic 3

Horror · RPG · Survival

PC · PlayStation 5 · Xbox Series X|S

Detective / MysteryPsychologicalSurreal+1
MysteriousUnsettlingThought-Provoking+3
Comment
CASSETTE BEASTS
9.1

CASSETTE BEASTS

RPG · Adventure

Nintendo Switch · Nintendo Switch Lite · Nintendo Switch OLED · Xbox One · Xbox Series X|S · PC · Linux · Steam · Microsoft Store

Sci-FiAlienFantasy+7
AdventurousExploratoryDiscovery-Driven+36
Comment
Persona 2: Innocent Sin
9.1

Persona 2: Innocent Sin

RPG

PlayStation · PlayStation Portable

Urban FantasySupernaturalPsychological+1
MysteriousDarkAtmospheric+3
Comment
Persona 2
9.1

Persona 2

RPG

PlayStation · PlayStation Portable

Urban FantasySupernaturalPsychological+1
MysteriousDarkAtmospheric+3
Comment
ENA: Dream BBQ
9.1

ENA: Dream BBQ

Adventure · Puzzle

Linux · macOS · Windows

SurrealDreamlikeComedy
MysteriousQuirkyWeird+3
Comment
Who's Lila?
9.1

Who's Lila?

Adventure · Horror · RPG

Windows

Detective / MysteryPsychologicalSurreal+1
MysteriousUnsettlingAtmospheric+2
Comment
Hashihime of the Old Book Town
9.0

Hashihime of the Old Book Town

Visual Novel · Adventure · Horror

PC · Nintendo Switch

ModernDetective / MysteryPsychological+1
MysteriousDarkUnsettling+3
Comment
Scarlet Hollow
9.0

Scarlet Hollow

Visual Novel · Horror · Adventure

PC · Mac · Linux

FolkloreSupernaturalGothic+1
MysteriousUnsettlingSuspenseful+2
Comment
THE MOON I ROT BEHIND
9.0

THE MOON I ROT BEHIND

Adventure · Horror

Roblox

PsychologicalSurrealDark / Grim
MysteriousCreepyUnsettling+3
Comment
Look Outside
9.0

Look Outside

RPG · Adventure · Horror

PC

PsychologicalSurrealDark / Grim
MysteriousUnsettlingAtmospheric+3
Comment
The 25th Ward: The Silver Case
9.0

The 25th Ward: The Silver Case

Adventure · Visual Novel · Puzzle

Mobile · Windows · macOS · Linux · PlayStation 4 · Nintendo Switch

CyberpunkDystopianDetective / Mystery+1
MysteriousDarkUnsettling+3
Comment
Isle
9.0

Isle

Horror · Survival · Adventure

PC · Mobile · Console

Detective / MysteryNature / WildernessPsychological+1
AdventurousExploratoryMysterious+3
Comment
ARMORED CORE
9.0

ARMORED CORE

Action · Simulation

PlayStation

ExploratoryBleakIntense+11
Comment
Wooden Ocean
8.9

Wooden Ocean

RPG

PC

Sci-FiDark FantasyPost-Apocalyptic+1
MysteriousAtmosphericSurreal+2
Comment
The Broken Script
8.9

The Broken Script

Horror

PC (Minecraft: Java Edition)

SupernaturalPsychologicalSurreal+1
MysteriousCreepyEerie+3
Comment
CAPTURED 2
8.9

CAPTURED 2

Action · Adventure · Horror · Puzzle · Survival

PC · Steam

SupernaturalContemporaryMonsters+4
ExploratoryDiscovery-DrivenMysterious+27
2 Comments
PSYCHOPOMP
8.9

PSYCHOPOMP

Action · Adventure · Horror

PC

PsychologicalSurrealDreamlike+1
MysteriousCreepyEerie+5
Comment
999: NINE HOURS, NINE PERSONS, NINE DOORS
8.9

999: NINE HOURS, NINE PERSONS, NINE DOORS

Adventure · Puzzle

Nintendo Switch · PlayStation · PC · Mobile

MysteriousExploratoryDiscovery-Driven+11
Comment
POINT OF NO RETURN
8.9

POINT OF NO RETURN

Adventure

Roblox

Detective / MysteryPsychologicalSurreal
MysteriousAtmosphericThought-Provoking+2
Comment
Rewrite
8.8

Rewrite

Visual Novel · Adventure

Microsoft Windows · PlayStation Portable · PlayStation Vita · PlayStation 3 · PlayStation 4

SupernaturalDystopianPsychological+1
MysteriousAtmosphericThought-Provoking+3
Comment
Sylbyte
8.8

Sylbyte

Shooter · Visual Novel

Roblox

Sci-FiPsychologicalDark / Grim
IntenseAtmosphericSingle-Player+2
Comment

Think The Belly got it wrong?Prove it.

Free account. Rate games, make predictions, and see your taste profile.

Join FreeAlready a member? Log in

Cookies. We use essential cookies to keep you logged in and the platform secure — no advertising trackers. By using Belly Score, you agree to our use of cookies. See our Privacy Policy for the details.

Privacy Policy