New Features Are Here!   Community Scores & Reviews Are LIVE!   Rate Games & Write Your Own Reviews!   Missing a Game? Request It!

Belly ScoreBELLYSCORE
Log InJoin Free
BELLYSCORE
VIBE

Best Mysterious Games

Every game with a Mysterious vibe, ranked by Belly Score. These are the titles The Belly felt hit that Mysterious note, sorted from the highest verdict down.

Games tagged with a Mysterious vibe, ranked by Belly Score. Vibe tags describe how a game feels to play — the mood and texture of the experience — so this list groups titles that share that Mysterious energy even across different genres. Browse to find games that hit the Mysterious note you're after, scored and verdict-ready.

Best Mysterious Games rankings

104 games
Rewrite
8.8

Rewrite

Visual Novel · Adventure

Microsoft Windows · PlayStation Portable · PlayStation Vita · PlayStation 3 · PlayStation 4

SupernaturalDystopianPsychological+1
MysteriousAtmosphericThought-Provoking+3
Comment
Lore Game
8.8

Lore Game

Adventure

PC · Mobile · Xbox · PlayStation

FantasyDetective / MysteryPsychological
MysteriousAtmosphericChallenging+2
Comment
7TH DRAGON III CODE: VFD
8.8

7TH DRAGON III CODE: VFD

RPG

Nintendo 3DS

ExploratoryDiscovery-DrivenAdventurous+10
Comment
late july, midsummer
8.8

late july, midsummer

Adventure

Roblox

SurrealDreamlike
ExploratoryDiscovery-DrivenMysterious+3
Comment
Shin Megami Tensei: Devil Summoner: Raidou Kuzunoha vs. The Soulless Army
8.8

Shin Megami Tensei: Devil Summoner: Raidou Kuzunoha vs. The Soulless Army

Action RPG · RPG · Action

PlayStation 2

Detective / MysteryUrban FantasyOccult+1
AtmosphericMysteriousStrategic+2
Comment
ALAN WAKE'S AMERICAN NIGHTMARE
8.7

ALAN WAKE'S AMERICAN NIGHTMARE

Action · Horror · Adventure

PC · Xbox

MysteriousExploratoryDiscovery-Driven+14
Comment
KinitoPET
8.7

KinitoPET

Horror · Simulation

PC

SupernaturalPsychologicalSurreal+1
MysteriousCreepyUnsettling+3
Comment
Jim's Computer
8.7

Jim's Computer

Horror · Simulation

Roblox

PsychologicalDark / Grim
MysteriousCreepyUnsettling+3
Comment
DELTARUNE
8.7
Community
8.8
1 rating

DELTARUNE

RPG

Windows · macOS · Nintendo Switch · Nintendo Switch 2 · PlayStation 4 · PlayStation 5

FantasySchool / AcademyPsychological+1
MysteriousFunnyQuirky+3
Comment
The Invincible
8.7

The Invincible

Adventure

PC · PlayStation 5 · Xbox Series X/S

Sci-FiSpaceAlien+1
MysteriousImmersiveAtmospheric+2
Comment
Dark Souls II
8.6
Community
9.3
1 rating

Dark Souls II

Action · RPG · Action RPG

PlayStation 3 · Xbox 360 · Windows · PlayStation 4 · Xbox One

Dark FantasyPsychologicalDark / Grim
MysteriousDarkChallenging+3
Comment
Metroid Prime 4: Beyond
8.4

Metroid Prime 4: Beyond

Action · Adventure · FPS

Nintendo Switch · Nintendo Switch 2

Sci-FiSpaceAlien+1
AdventurousExploratoryDiscovery-Driven+3
Comment
Ecco the Dolphin
8.4

Ecco the Dolphin

Action · Adventure

Sega Genesis · Sega CD · Sega Master System · Sega Game Gear · PC · Macintosh · Linux · Xbox 360 · iOS · Nintendo 3DS · Web

Sci-FiUnderwaterNature / Wilderness+1
AdventurousMysteriousChallenging+3
Comment
Dupery: A Game of Solo Deduction
8.4

Dupery: A Game of Solo Deduction

Strategy · Puzzle

PC · Mac

NoirDetective / MysteryCrime+1
MysteriousSuspensefulStrategic+3
Comment
ROUTINE
8.3

ROUTINE

Adventure · Horror · Survival

PC · Xbox Series X|S · Xbox One

Sci-FiSpaceRobots / Mechs+1
MysteriousAtmosphericTense+3
Comment
CROSS†CHANNEL
8.3

CROSS†CHANNEL

Adventure

PC · PlayStation 2 · PlayStation Portable · Xbox 360 · PlayStation 3 · PlayStation Vita · Nintendo Switch

PsychologicalModernSchool / Academy+1
MysteriousUnsettlingEmotional+3
Comment
Fractal Block World
8.0

Fractal Block World

Action · Adventure

PC (Microsoft Windows)

Sci-FiSurrealDreamlike
ExploratoryDiscovery-DrivenMysterious+3
Comment
OMORI: REVERIE
7.8

OMORI: REVERIE

RPG

PsychologicalSurrealDreamlike+1
MysteriousEmotionalMelancholic+3
Comment
Once A Normal City
7.8

Once A Normal City

Action · Survival · Shooter

Roblox

DystopianDark / GrimPsychological
MysteriousEerieTense+3
Comment
BANISHERS: GHOSTS OF NEW EDEN
7.8

BANISHERS: GHOSTS OF NEW EDEN

Action · RPG · Adventure

PlayStation 5 · Xbox Series X|S · PC · Steam · Epic Games Store · GOG

AdventurousExploratoryDiscovery-Driven+32
Comment
Frozen Soul [DG]
7.7

Frozen Soul [DG]

Adventure · Sandbox

PC · Mobile

FantasySupernaturalPsychological+1
MysteriousAtmosphericDreamlike+3
Comment
ATOMIC HEART
7.7

ATOMIC HEART

Action · RPG · FPS · Adventure

PlayStation 4 · PlayStation 5 · Xbox One · Xbox Series X|S · PC · Steam · Microsoft Store

AdventurousExploratoryDiscovery-Driven+35
Comment
sun, moon, and star. to these i bid adieu
7.6

sun, moon, and star. to these i bid adieu

Adventure

Roblox

PsychologicalSurrealDreamlike
ExploratoryMysteriousWeird+3
Comment
Starship Titanic
7.6

Starship Titanic

Adventure

Windows · Mac OS · Linux · ScummVM

Sci-FiSpaceRobots / Mechs+1
ExploratoryMysteriousFunny+3
Comment

Think The Belly got it wrong?Prove it.

Free account. Rate games, make predictions, and see your taste profile.

Join FreeAlready a member? Log in

Cookies. We use essential cookies to keep you logged in and the platform secure — no advertising trackers. By using Belly Score, you agree to our use of cookies. See our Privacy Policy for the details.

Privacy Policy